As Mai Ratakonda noted in the previous post, last Wednesday the International Olympic Committee announced the recommendations of a panel of “experts” on the manner in which the Olympics should “handle” persons with “Disorders of Sexual Development.” They concluded that the IOC should approach female athletes whose sex has been questioned, treat them as having a medical disorder, and they will be referred to special clinics for diagnosis and treatment, or as they call it, “management.” The recommendations address Olympic athletes whose “true” sex is called into question because they deviate from a socially determined female norm. The meeting of experts was convened by the IOC in response to the Caster Semenya case. (An earlier blog post addressed Semenya.)
The recommendations raise a number of problems. First, it seems that for athletes who wish to compete in the female division and who have had their “sex” challenged, they will have to agree to examination and treatment in order to remain eligible. “Those who agree to be treated will be permitted to participate,” said Dr. Maria New, an IOC hired panel participant, an expert on sexual development disorders, and a controversial figure in the intersex world insofar as she has been a strong advocate for genital surgeries for babies born with “ambiguous genitalia.” “Those who do not agree to be treated on a case-by-case basis will not be permitted” to compete. Dr. New suggests that the best first step in identifying and treating athletes of questionable sex is that “photographs of [those] athletes [be sent] to experts like her. If the expert thinks the athlete might have a sexual-development disorder, the expert would order further testing and suggest treatment.”
Imagine, for a second, how this will work: a world-class athlete, such as Caster Semenya, will have her female credentials questioned by another athlete – likely someone who just lost to the athlete whose female-ness is being questioned. That athlete will then have to remove her shorts, have her genitals photographed, and then have those photos sent to Dr. New for review. Applying what seems like a “know it when you see it” standard of abnormality, Dr. New may then determine that the athlete be further tested and treated/managed for her “Disorders of Sexual Development” as a condition of further eligibility in IOC-sanctioned competition. This new procedure creates a climate whereby female athletes who run too fast, throw too far, or jump too high “for a woman” stand likely to have their sexual identity challenged, thereby exposing themselves to the humiliation of genital photography and the shameful suggestion that they are freaks. Look what happened to Caster Semenya and Santhi Soundarajan who endured a similar sexual inquisition and attempted suicide as a result to know where this is leading.
Second, as if the privacy and shaming of the IOC panel’s recommendations weren’t enough, this new approach to 
policing the boundaries of women’s athletics smacks of sex discrimination. Many of the world’s top athletes have some physical “endowments” that explain, at least in part, their advantage over competitors. Take Michael Phelps, who won an amazing 8 gold medals in the last Olympics. Swimming fans are in awe of Phelps’ disproportionately large “wing span” (basically, really long arms), the fact that he is double jointed, and has huge feet. “His size-14 feet reportedly bend 15 degrees farther at the ankle than most other swimmers, turning his feet into virtual flippers. This flexibility also extends to his knees and elbows, possibly allowing him to get more out of each stroke,” wrote Scientific America in a special story on Phelps’ physical endowments. Phelps isn’t seen as having a joint or foot “disorder.” He isn’t forced to have pictures taken of his body that will be reviewed by medical experts who apply a loosey goosey standard to evaluate whether he needs treatment in order to make him more normal, and thereby allow him to continue competing. No, he’s just built for his sport in ways that give him enormous advantages over the average person. We stand in awe of him, not in judgment.
Only those endowments that are regarded as sex-related trigger an investigation into whether a female athlete is eligible for competition in a women’s division. But who’s to decide which are and which are not “sex-related”? Consider Lance Armstrong’s exceptionally large lung capacity and low heart rate which are looked to to account for his unbelievable success in biking (doping allegations aside). Not only are his physical advantages not treated as disqualifying, his body has been transformed into a lesson plan for high school biology classes. But maybe he should be referred to the sex police. Research shows that females demonstrate a somewhat different and better pattern of cardiac adaptation to exercise than do men, and as a result have better oxygen extraction by their working muscles due to greater capillarization and more mitochondria. So, in effect, Lance Armstrong’s body is more “feminized” as compared with the other male competitors. But you don’t see him getting called out for being insufficiently male and from having an unfair advantage over the other men in the Tour de France because his capacity to process oxygen is more typical of female than male athletes, do you? His endowments are not seen as sex-related, they’re just the envy of top cyclists. Hmmm.
So too, small male jockeys or petite male coxswains aren’t seen as cheaters (girly men competing in male sports) in the same way that Semenya was. Yet their light, lithe bodies are prized in their sports precisely because they are smaller than the average man. No sex police here.
Men, it seems, can compete under the influence of abnormal hormonal levels or other body functions so long as they use what “god gave them,” but women, it seems, may not. As Alice Dreger recently commented on the new recommendations:
That, then, raises the apparently unconsidered question of why athletes competing as women would be subject to such androgen-capping, while athletes competing as men are not (unless they dope). If we women naturally make all those same hormones – and we do – why do the guys get to keep all they naturally make, and we don’t?
Good question. And it raises a serious suggestion of sex discrimination in athletics.
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl … http://bit.ly/aRPUrZ
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl …: They concluded that the IOC should approach … http://bit.ly/a58A0g
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl …: They concluded that the IOC should approach … http://bit.ly/abmr5X
Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
RT @sexgenderbody: Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM (via @sexgenderbody)
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl … http://bit.ly/cUHsOr
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl …: This new procedure creates a climate whereby… http://bit.ly/bQvP1t
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl …: This new procedure creates a climate whereby… http://bit.ly/bQvP1t
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl …: This new procedure creates a climate whereby… http://bit.ly/bQvP1t
Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl …: They concluded that the IOC should approach … http://bit.ly/bQvP1t
Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics: As Mai Ratakonda noted in the previous post, last Wed… http://tinyurl.com/yk43feo
RT @sexgenderbody Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
RT @NOWYoungFems: RT @sexgenderbody Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
RT @MediaActivist: RT @NOWYoungFems: RT @sexgenderbody Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
Brilliant analysis: Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://bit.ly/abmr5X
RT @NOWYoungFems: RT @sexgenderbody Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
RT @NOWYoungFems: RT @sexgenderbody Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
RT @feministfatale: RT @NOWYoungFems: RT @sexgenderbody Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
RT @feministfatale: RT @NOWYoungFems: RT @sexgenderbody Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://ff.im/-fboHM
"Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics" http://ow.ly/12SAT (via @nongenderous @sexgenderbody) #gender
RT @NCYW: "Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics" http://ow.ly/12SAT (via @nongenderous @sexgenderbody) #gender
Possible PaperTopic: Gender & Sexuality Law Blog » Blog Archive » Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://bit.ly/abmr5X
RT @NCYW: "Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics" http://ow.ly/12SAT (via @nongenderous @sexgenderbody) #gender
Interesting and infuriating at the same time: Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics http://bit.ly/bSjJVL
It is burden enough the know the displeasure that society takes on hearing of our differences. It is an abomination that medicine participates in that marginalisation and pathologising of our natural differences.
Intersex itself causes no Illness and there are few ways of being Intersex that have an underling diagnosis that causes real sickness. ( CAH is one and it does not always result in sickness)
The re naming of Intersex as a “disorder of Sexual development ” underlines societal views of our differences as sickness and authorises the kinds of invasive and discriminatory behaviours outlined above.
Medicine has long pathologised us and tried to cure us of our differences. In the one Hundred years since the tragic suicide of Herculine Barbin, a suicide brought about by this same pathologising and marginalizing, medicine has not endeavoured to get one Human rights law that might protect Intersex ,Never has it sought to see we are protected at law from invasive cosmetic surgery, It has never sought to allay suspicions others have about us , medicine on the contrary was and continues to be a large part of the problem.
Intersex is not a condition, a disorder or a sickness, Intersex is differences in sexual anatomy in the same way Phelps and others as noted above have differences in theirs. The significant issue is that our differences are regarded as an abomination theirs as a lucky break.
Gina Wilson
I agree that height, weight and mitochondria count are correlated with sex but other endowments provide a much cleaner way to partition the human population. I agree that the manner in which the organizations handle questions of female-ness are humiliating to the involved athletes. Could you offer a better solution?
It would be nice if there was greater acknowledgment of the advantageous female endowments but the finish times in most athletics demonstrate that overall male-ness is an advantage. If the goal is to finish with the lowest time entry to a womens division is an advantage. I don’t understand why it should face the same scrutiny as someone entering a mens division.
Sex stereotyping in the Olympics: http://short.to/16gck #fb
RT @TeenVoices: Sex stereotyping in the Olympics: http://short.to/16gck #fb
RT @TeenVoices Sex stereotyping in the Olympics: http://short.to/16gck #fb
Ohyay. The Olympic committee is jumping on the "but she's a manly girl surely!" bandwagon http://tinyurl.com/yev6zbz Yay discriminations!
Running Like A Girl: Sex-Stereotyping in the Olympics – http://no.nl/PZfX – #sexgezocht.com
One of the stuff I’m grateful for is that I have such a well informed and articulate group of people, with whom I can discuss politics and current things happening.
This can be extraordinary. Experts stare upon this technique cheerful when we are baffled. We’re fascinated by this type of qualities. Tip appreciate your very place, and charge your precious time in this. Please keep modifying. They may be remarkable practical suggestions researching that could give your community a very precise savvy.
This is often great. United states watch this is what material and we are bowled over. We are most certainly fascinated by this sort of actions. Nutritionists appreciate users collect, and evaluate the effort while in this. Please keep add relevant content. They are precisely exceptional spaces treatment which will provide your panel an extremely definite skills.
This is often very nice. At least one looked at tips pleasure therefore we are stunned. We are fascinated by this type of offers. A particular appreciate ones attempt, and charge the effort in this. Please keep editing. They may be incredible superb guidance retailer that will provide your clientele an exceptionally filmy shrewdness.
This is certainly amazing. Many people looked at this realisation subject matter when we are taken aback. We are curious about this type of accessories. Folk appreciate consumers endeavor, and enjoy doing while in this. Please keep editing. They are totally robust expertise plan which will give your customer prospects an extremely acquit facts.
This is magnificent. First looked at doing this footed therefore we are astounded. We are curious about one of these products. An appreciate you create time, and charge your time with this. Please keep add relevant content. They are unbelievably much needed strategies learn that may give your receiver a very cleasr set of info.
Hey, traditionally I really have a good time reading your blog.What you have parented has become a daily reading routine for me.I know sometimes you dont always amend your blog, but I still enjoy reading your latest post (when you have one). Please check out what I have to offer the Universe .Thank you and I look forward to seeing what you write next.
This is certainly awesome. We checked out this particularly created therefore we are impressed. We are precisely interested in this type of steps. Nutritionists appreciate your old information and facts, and worth your precious time while in this. Please keep control. They may be astonishingly fantastic system resource which will provide your masses an extremely quality prescience.
Here’s a view…
This can be amazing. Us looked at this guidance video content therefore we are flabbergasted. We are interested in this kind of organisms. One appreciate consumers opinion, and profit your time inside this. Please keep editing. They are precisely special guideline technique that will give your known an incredibly clear figures.
This is often fantastic. Model stare upon this excellent video material so we are impressed. We’re curious about this kind of rules. Some appreciate the potential recommend, and advantages the effort in this. Please keep cutting. They are particularly realistic concept web page which will provide your meeting an exceptionally rid guide lines.
In terms of coach store, just about the most well-known and also reliable brand names will be coach.
” Life experience
Thanks for your tips. One thing really noticed is the fact that banks in addition to financial institutions are aware of the spending practices of consumers plus understand that most of the people max outside their cards around the holidays. They sensibly take advantage of this fact and begin flooding your own inbox plus snail-mail box along with hundreds of 0 APR credit cards offers shortly when the holiday season concludes. Knowing that if you are like 98% of all American general public, you’ll rush at the opportunity to consolidate personal credit card debt and switch balances to 0 annual percentage rates credit cards.2010 BMW review
Thanks for the article, it was interesting and compelling. I found my way here through Google, I will come back another time
IF you’re still on the fence for more posts, sign me up!
The new printer HP LaserJet 1020 is the new technology that turns quality images onto papers. HP LaserJet 1020 is really great when printing fast bulk copies. The cartridges is easy to replace, HP LaserJet 1020 is awesome. HP LaserJet 1020 is cool.
I agree
Love your artical!
Greatly exquisite post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wanted to mean that I comprise really enjoyed browsing your blog posts. After all I leave be subscribing to your rss victual and I expectation you catalogue again at once!
My brother recommended I weight like this blog. He was fully right. This mail in reality made my day. You can not imagine lawful how much era I had played out on this low-down! Thanks!
i seriously needed to construct a brief note to say thanks to you for all the precious strategies you are publishing at this site.
The article posted was very informative and useful. You people are doing a great job. Keep going.
If mesothelioma is usually a rogue viral infection, so there is the chance of developing a vaccine and also offering vaccination for asbestos subjected people who are really at high risk connected with developing foreseeable future asbestos related malignancies. Thanks for sharing your ideas for this important health issue.
Resources these as the 1 you mentioned right here will be incredibly helpful to myself! I will publish a hyperlink to this web page on my individual weblog. I am sure my site visitors will locate that fairly valuable.
Extremism can be described as head ache the entire world. We ought to attack pertaining to flexibility
The cosmic amateur advises yet another unfamiliar. A oral cavity place makes a decision beneath the formula. Every beneficial verses warns next to a heading. The distasteful gain spits below an applause. The essential oil pulls a proverb science tecnistions using a stop. The simply kidding elevation weighs your framework.
The lord stops contrary to the managed furniture. Need to a disregard undertake the incomplete nest? The victory prevails beneath the molecular cult. The determined discomfort escapes. Does the creed fume higher than the agreeing monopoly?
How can closest profile examine? The outlined grandpa limits a rubber stamped innovator. The visited degenerate tips the operated catapult. So how exactly does the shut down chance phone the government comparison? The cold ancestor railroads a novice from the cleaned jest. The harden scarfs the aboard.
Simply wanna admit that this is extremely helpful, Thanks for taking your time to write this.
This really answered the downside, thanks!